Theus Wealth Advisors
All articles

Open Enrollment Decisions Federal Employees Can't Afford to Rush

BlogNovember 18, 20254 min readJ’Neanne Theus

Every fall, federal employees and retirees get a short window to make changes to their health benefits. It is called Open Season, and it covers FEHB health insurance and FSA elections. I talk with federal families all year about their pensions, their TSP, and their retirement timelines, and I can tell you that Open Season is one of the most overlooked parts of the whole picture. People spend hours agonizing over TSP fund allocations and then spend five minutes on their health plan because the deadline snuck up on them.

That is backwards. Your health coverage choice affects your monthly budget, your access to care, and in retirement it can shape your options for years to come. It deserves more than a rubber stamp.

Why Open Season deserves real attention

If you do nothing during Open Season, your current FEHB plan typically continues. That default is designed for convenience, not necessarily for your benefit. Plans change their premiums, coverage details, and networks from one year to the next. The plan that fit your life well last year might not be the best fit this year, especially if your health needs, your family situation, or your provider network has shifted.

Federal employees and retirees have more plan choices than most private-sector workers. That is a genuine advantage, but it only pays off if you actually compare your options instead of letting the same plan roll forward out of habit.

Common mistakes I see

Auto-renewing without reviewing plan changes

The easiest mistake is also the most common one. Life gets busy, the Open Season emails pile up, and the plan you had last year just continues. The problem is that insurers routinely adjust premiums, deductibles, and covered services. A plan can look similar on the surface and still cost you meaningfully more, or cover less, than it did twelve months ago.

Not comparing premiums vs. out-of-pocket costs

It is tempting to shop by premium alone, since that is the number that hits your paycheck every pay period. But a lower premium plan with a higher deductible, higher copays, or a narrower network can end up costing more over a year, particularly if you or a family member sees specialists regularly or takes maintenance medications. The real comparison is total expected cost: premium plus what you are likely to pay out of pocket given your actual health care use.

Forgetting to reconsider FSA elections

Flexible Spending Account elections reset every year. Whatever you elected last year does not automatically continue, and the amount that made sense for you then may not make sense now. If your family's medical or dependent care expenses have changed, your FSA election should change with them. Skipping this step either leaves money on the table or locks you into contributing more than you will actually use.

Not coordinating health plan choice with Medicare

If you or a family member has recently become eligible for Medicare, your FEHB decision gets more complicated, not less. How FEHB and Medicare work together depends on your specific plan and your enrollment choices, and getting this wrong can mean paying for coverage you do not need or missing coordination that would have saved you money. This is exactly the kind of decision worth walking through with someone who knows both systems, rather than guessing.

A practical framework for reviewing your options

  • Pull your current plan's updated materials. Before you compare anything, read what your current plan looks like for the coming year. Note any changes to premiums, deductibles, copays, or covered providers.
  • List your actual health care use from the past year. Doctor visits, prescriptions, procedures, family coverage needs. This grounds your comparison in reality instead of guesswork.
  • Compare two or three realistic alternatives. You do not need to review every plan available to you. Pick the ones that seem like plausible fits and run the numbers side by side: premium plus expected out-of-pocket costs.
  • Revisit your FSA election with fresh eyes. Base it on what you expect to spend next year, not what you contributed last year out of habit.
  • Flag any Medicare coordination questions. If you are newly eligible or about to become eligible, treat this as its own conversation rather than an afterthought.
  • Make your decision before the window closes. Whatever you decide, decide on purpose. A deliberate choice to keep your current plan is very different from an accidental one.

When to talk with us

Health benefits decisions do not happen in isolation. They connect to your broader retirement income picture, your pension, your TSP strategy, and how you plan to cover health care costs in retirement. If you are weighing FEHB options, thinking through Medicare coordination, or just want a second set of eyes before Open Season closes, it is worth having that conversation sooner rather than later. We are happy to schedule a call with us to walk through your specific situation.

Keep reading

Blog

Iron Laws of the Stock Market

It’s been an interesting half year in the market. I heard a podcast listener ask: If there are no iron laws in markets and nothing works forever as an indicator, perhaps studying the stock market is u…

August 18, 2025 3 min read

Blog

Qualified Accounts and Non-Spousal Heirs – the Conundrum

We’ve spoken about this topic a few times, but it’s worth revisiting from time to time. There were 90 changes to this act last year. And per usual, the acronyms given often represent the opposite of w…

August 18, 2025 2 min read

A conversation is a good place to start

Bring us the questions
keeping you up at night.

Schedule a conversation